Your website, your Google listing, your reviews and your referring doctors all did their job. They brought that patient to your number. Then the phone rang out.
Adding another receptionist doesn't fix nights, weekends or the 8 a.m. rush. You'd pay a full salary for a few busy hours a day, and the phone still rings when that person is at lunch.
Generic answering services take a message and leave the booking to your team tomorrow. By then the patient has booked somewhere else, and you've paid twice: once for the marketing that made the phone ring, and once for the message nobody could act on.
You don't have a marketing problem. You have a phone problem.
An illustration, not a guarantee. Run it with your own call volume and your own share of new-patient calls.